___
Reported: 20th October 2025
Financial remedies hearing, in which the issue was how much should be deducted from H’s entitlement of £6.4m under a pre-nuptial agreement ‘PNA’, having regard to his conduct and sums already received. H awarded £2.3m.
Facts
W aged 42 years is described as enormously wealthy, H aged 35 years with a net worth of £650,000 at the time the parties entered into a PNA. Married in October 2019 following cohabitation earlier that year, separated in May 2023 although W’s account is Autumn of 2022. H’s net worth (personal wealth) according to his Form E dated September 2023 was £4.25m. The parties PNA disapplies the principles of compensation and sharing. Under the PNA, H was entitled to an increasing sum based on the length of the marriage. It is accepted that the duration of the marriage for the purposes of the PNA is some 4 years, which produces for the husband a lump sum of £6.4m at the marriage’s end, in addition to retaining his own Separate Property, his share of any joint property, and any gain from ‘seed capital’ as defined in their agreement. It is accepted that the total entitlement figure before any issues are considered would be £6,449,802.
Background
This is the third substantive judgment in these proceedings, the first being reported as Loh v Ardal Loh-Gronager [2024] EWFC 241 (‘the chattels judgment’) and the second as Y v Z [2025] EWFC 221 (‘the conduct judgment’) [1]. The PNA which the parties recorded is a key feature of this case, and whether and how H’s conduct impacts the PNA. Another issue was to determine how much of the value already received by H should be treated as his Separate Property under the agreement and how much should be treated as receipt by him on account of entitlement i.e. how much, if any should be removed from the £6.4m entitlement.
The law
The test/principle in Radmacher and conduct under s25(2)(g) should be applied together; one goes primarily to the fair implementation of the agreement, the other to broader fairness [59]. It seems that Mr Justice Cusworth reasons that once he concludes that H’s behaviour ‘comfortably’ crosses the s25(2)(g) threshold, any possible tension between the application of the two tests is disapplied. [60]
Conduct
At [64-65] H’s conduct in the proceedings was criticised, justifying the Judge’s decision that the s25(2)(g) threshold was crossed. The conduct which was considered included his actions in the improper use of funds in contradiction to the agreement. H took funds from the joint account when he was not authorised to do so and used some funds for investing into Separate Property with the knowledge and understanding that each person would retain Separate Property in the event of a relationship breakdown. He was criticised for holding on to the argument that those funds then became his until the conclusion of the trial. H was found to have used callous and deliberate means to upset W in the hope that she would be persuaded to drop the case leaving him with the outcome he was seeking. He was found to have denigrated and criticised W through his evidence and accuse her of dishonesty in relation to the documents. H produced false evidence to the court including emails where it appears to have blind copied W. This was described as ‘the most serious level of litigation misconduct that may be seen in these courts.’ At [22], the judgment reads, ‘… it is clear to see that the husband has had the means, the opportunity and the motive to create and doctor the disputed emails. On the balance of probabilities, I have no hesitation in finding that he has done so.’ A layered issue because the court grappled with whether there was unfairness to W in circumstances where she says she might have treated the payments in the same way had she been told they were made. Notwithstanding, the court considered that H’s actions including omissions were a significant factor to determine the balance of fairness [65]. The court was firm in its finding that H’s conduct was premeditated; at [67] reads, ‘Indeed, the fact that the husband began to take amounts from the joint account almost as soon as it was set up suggests that he has throughout the marriage been preparing the ground for as lucrative a separation as he could contrive.’
Outcome
The court deemed three sums as H taking/receiving those on account of his entitlement under the PNA; those three sums did not reduce H’s entitlement because of his conduct, instead they flowed naturally from the Judge’s findings. (1) The £1m taken by H on 8 April 2023 was not treated as Separate Property but was treated as a sum already received by him on account of his entitlement under the PNA. (2) Similarly, the £2.05m taken by H from the mortgage account in November 2022 and paid by him into LGP was considered a sum already received by him on account of his entitlement under the PNA. (3) The payment of £655,000 which H invested into LPG was also treated as being taken on account of his entitlement under the PNA. [57]
H’s conduct factored into the sum of £750,000 which he took from the joint account upon treating it as joint expenses. H’s entitlement under the PNA was reduced by half of that sum i.e. £375,000. Wife had knowledge and acknowledged that she would have approved of that use. Notwithstanding, W invites the court to reduce H’s £6.4m entitlement under the PNA by this sum because of his conduct – conduct set out above and also in consideration of fairness by applying the principle in Radmacher v Granatino [2010] UKSC 42, Lord Phillips at [75] of that Judgment said: ‘The court should give effect to a nuptial agreement that is freely entered into by each party with a full appreciation of its implications unless in the circumstances prevailing it would not be fair to hold the parties to their agreement.’ H knew that by using joint funds that was set aside for joint expenses, which he says were gifts, to transfer and invest into accounts in his own name (use for a purpose outside of its intent), thereby making them Separate Property would directly impact the term in the deed which reads, ‘neither will acquire any interest in the other’s Separate Property unless it has become Joint Property’. Mr Justice Cusworth notes that where the implementation of a PNA has been in issue the courts have been less constrained in the application of the principle of fairness. [58ff].
The final decision did not factor in the impact of any probable costs orders.
________